The 6 String Banjo Puzzle (article published in the Banjo Newsletter)


The 6-string banjo is as hard to classify as a platypus duckbill. It has been around for more than a century. It has a guitar neck, so it is really a guitar. Except that when you play one for most people or show it to them, they say "Nice banjo." (Or they say "Sure is a loud banjo.") Even when you take the time to explain to people that it is a 6-string banjo and not a "real" banjo and is essentially a guitar, they are not swayed. It is like telling people that a horse is a dog. They won't buy it. Looks like one, sounds like one, must be one. Unless, of course, they are 5-string banjo players. To a 5-string player, the 6-string banjo is a guitar. Since there are only a few 5-string players in the world to deny that it is a banjo, and the other 5.9 billion would say that it is a banjo, democracy dictates that it is truly a banjo. Except that this is Banjo Newsletter, and most of you readers are probably 5-string players, so I'm not going to push the point.


Whatever it is, I have had a 6-string banjo and enjoyed it immensely since 1988. Is it an instrument or a monster? It is neither a guitar or a banjo, though it is a member of the banjo family and a member of the guitar family. You can't make it sound like a guitar, even if you play the Bonanza theme on it. It sounds like a banjo. If you are clever, you can make it sound extremely like a 5-string banjo. If you do it really well, people, including musicians who are not looking carefully, just assume that you're playing a banjo. The average person might wonder why you won't play Deliverance or Beverly Hillbillies, which you can't, because those are 5-string tunes. It gets lonely, because the only people who can really appreciate how well you have imitated a 5-string banjo are 5-string banjo players, and they don't always appreciate it. You are sort of piddling on their fire hydrant.


So what is it good for? If you are a guitar player, it is a way to get banjo sounds without having to learn the banjo. It is even capable of many things a 5-string cannot do. It has a lower tone. It has more sustain. You can play counterpoint and bass lines, and escape from the "drone zone" more than with a 5-string. You can move the key center more easily away from the drone chord. If you are a solo player, it is probably most effective. It takes a different right hand attack than a guitar, and some of your friends will not be able to get to square one with it, yet you can jump back and forth between it and a guitar rather easily once you get the hang of it. It's a nice way to add some spice to a performance if you play guitar, much like the way most people use a 12-string guitar. If you play with a guitar player who can provide some rhythm (it can't really play the same kind of rhythm a guitar does, being instead more capable of the rhythms a banjo can provide), you can do some nice rolls, and make a sound that is very much like bluegrass. It may be the ultimate ragtime guitar. You can mimic the sound of a lot of styles of banjo playing, from bluegrass to clawhammer to Irish to Dixieland. Chuck Berry licks work quite well. Baroque music sounds great on it, as does celtic. To me, it is a real instrument, and it is full of surprises, and I am always startled at the kinds of sounds I can coax out of it, and also the kinds of things that just don't work very well, though you would think they would.


It's my opinion that because it has more strings, a wider pitch range, and more sustain than a 5-string, it is therefore capable of a wider range of musical expression than a 5-string, though admittedly in a bluegrass situation the 6-string cannot generate the cascades of notes the way a 5-string can. Since to most people's ears, the sound of a fast 5-string playing Scruggs style IS the banjo, the 6-string then isn't quite a banjo. However, (there is always a however in the world of 6-string banjo) if you are just looking to express yourself and play a lot of music, it is a powerful and useful tool, and may help push the sound of the banjo forward into some new kinds of music. The essence of "banjo-ness" is fundamentally connected to the tone, more so than to the tuning of the instrument. So don't be afraid to play one, and don't think less of those of us who do. I love the 5-string as much as anyone. Honest.

©1999 by Harvey Reid
----------------------------------------------------
Harvey Reid is a musician and writer who lives in York, Maine, who has recorded 32 albums on Woodpecker Records (http://www.woodpecker.com) including the only CD ever made of entirely 6 and 12-string banjo music: Artistry of the 6-String Banjo

WOODPECKER MULTIMEDIA
PO Box 815 York Maine 03909  USA
phone (207) 363-1886


Lyrics About Harvey Reid
Concert Schedule Lyrics
Catalog of Recordings Buy From Us
Say Hello to Us Booking Information
Books The Song Train
Newest Recording About Joyce Andersen
Newsletter About the Partial Capo
Listen to Audio Lyrics
Hot News Listen to Audio
Guitar Tunings Interviews
Articles & Essays Reviews
Publicity Info Out of Print Music
Publicity Photos Lyrics
Downloads Listen to Audio
Say Hello to Us Favorite CD's
Harvey's Gear  

Harvey Reid Concert Schedule |Harvey's Blog | About the Liberty Guitar Method|Catalog of CD's and Tapes|Discography|About this Web Site & What's New Here | Hot News | Woodpecker Home Page | About Harvey Reid |The Song Train | Video | Audio | About Joyce Andersen | Books by Harvey Reid | Get On the Mailing List... | Concert & Record Reviews | Interviews with HR | Lyrics to Harvey Reid Songs | Harvey Reid Annual Newsletters | HR's Guitar Tunings | About the Partial Capo | Articles & Essays by HR | HR's Gear | HR's Favorite CD's | HR's Career History | Booking Info | Publicity Info & Download Files |


This web site concerns the music and life of acoustic musician & music educator Harvey Reid.

If you don't find what you want, or if you have comments or questions, please email to